Time to Move On
June 10, 2011 Leave a comment
I did a bad job updating this blog, but Alas, there is some life after death!
Check out my new project at http://www.thecivilattorney.net … I’ll be blogging there from now on!
June 10, 2011 Leave a comment
I did a bad job updating this blog, but Alas, there is some life after death!
Check out my new project at http://www.thecivilattorney.net … I’ll be blogging there from now on!
December 12, 2010 Leave a comment
I hope everyone is enjoying the holiday season. It’s been quiet lately on the Louisiana Speech Law front.
See something you think would make a good post? E-mail me at laspeechlaw@gmail.com
November 23, 2010 Leave a comment
We’ve got a URL… tell your friends!
November 22, 2010 Leave a comment
This weekend I had the pleasure (?) of watching LSU narrowly get by the University of Mississippi, a school which recently passed on Star Wars’ Admiral Ackbar to somehow name the Louisiana Black Bear as its new mascot.
In between watching Jordan Jefferson have the game of his life (he finally hit someone in stride!) and before taking picture with star RB (and fellow Trinity alumnus) Stevan Ridley, I watched the student section to see if the infamous “Neck” would be played.
As we detailed in an earlier post, “Neck” was banned for some rather — ahem — questionable language. Alas, the Golden Band from Tiger Land did not play “Neck,” a quiet death for a new but fan-favorite cheer. However, in the third quarter I did notice that the students, sans music from the band, were doing the “Neck” cheer and screaming the “questionable language” in some sort of rebellion. Also, the student section started a “Refs, you suck” chant after a particularly awful call went against LSU.
Apparently you can take the music away, but the ranting goes on, a capella.
November 22, 2010 Leave a comment
In tough economic times like these, public access to records becomes incredibly important. Some of the best reporting and watchdog-ing comes from public records requests.
This weekend the Baton Rouge Advocate came out for a change in the public records law allowing state and local officials to submit documents electronically: http://www.2theadvocate.com/opinion/109542089.html
Texas and Mississippi have already moved in this direction, as the editorial points out, and it seems to make a lot of sense. Plus, it saves paper, which is always nice.
In recent years “reforms” to the public records laws have actually made it harder for the public to access documents, as a forthcoming Louisiana Law Review article spells out quite convincingly. I hope to have an interview with that article’s author, Kevin Blanchard, as soon as the article goes to press.
November 17, 2010 Leave a comment
Although I won’t be able to attend this evening, I’ve heard nothing but good things about these panel discussions over at LHC. If you’re in the Big Easy tonight, check it out.
TONIGHT AT 7PM, the LHC continues “The New Orleans Media: A Series of Panel Discussions on the Fourth Estate in the City.” The third installment, “Figaro, The Vieux Carre Courier, and The Lens: Investigative Journalism Past & Present,” features Steve Beatty and Karen Gadbois from The Lens, Jeanette Hardy, former publisher of The Vieux Carre Courier, and moderator Jack Davis, former editor of Figaro. Doors open at 6:45 and the panel is free and open to the public.
The LHC is located at 938 Lafayette Street, on the corner of O’Keefe in the Central Business District. Parking is available in the rear of the building. For more information, contact Brian Boyles at boyles@leh.org.
November 15, 2010 3 Comments

UPDATE: A reader chimes in that perhaps Tiger Stadium is a non-public forum, and by that logic LSU would need no justification other than reasonableness and neutral viewpoint to prohibit vulgar speech. Furthermore, he suggests that the Captive Audience theory strikes home because viewers have paid to watch football and not to hear vulgar cheers. He also points out that there are broadcasting questions, in that the broadcaster of those games wouldn’t want to run afoul of the FCC by sending the questionable (and unpredictable) cheers over the public’s airwaves. All valid points.
**Be warned, some offensive language is used in linked videos**
Our Alma Mater the Ole War Skule has a controversy that’s been brewing for a few football seasons now… the LSU Football Student Section’s obscenity laced chants.
During the 2007 National Championship run this was a major issue, when “F*** you Spurrier (and later Saban)!” could be loudly heard during the LSU-South Carolina game (which featured this amazing Colt David-Matt Flynn fake field goal). Other questionable cheers included “Teabag Tebow” during the Florida game and adding “You Suck” to the end of the traditional “Oh-Wee-Oh” touchdown dance.
The students’ cussin’ creativity marinated and has reared its head again this season, and especially during the nationally televised Nov. 6 matchup with between LSU and Alabama in Tiger Stadium. In that game, clapping chants of “F*** you Saban” were heard and the students have clearly appended “Suck that Tiger D***” (link from the Tenn. game) to the new-but-crowd-favorite “Neck” cheer.
The administration’s reaction has been to simply take the songs that spur the chants away. Sensitivity has been a hallmark recently, with concerns that the fourth-down “Chinese Bandits” cheer might also disappear because it is offensive to Asian-Americans. The traditional “Tiger Rag” disappeared during the 2006 season, mainly because the students had traditionally chanted “Assholes, Assholes” to the end of the cheer. But, Tiger Rag had been around since the early 1970s, and the “assholes” addendum was nothing new.
Along with LSU football’s rise from above-average to college football powerhouse comes a newer question of marketing and image. Now, I won’t take a stance on whether it’s a wise decision to chant in such a way, but legal? Well that is why we’re here, isn’t it. LSU is acting the best way it knows how — by taking the cheers away (to the chagrin of fans and students alike). Telling the band not to play a certain song doesn’t really implicate any Free Expression rights. But what if the administration chose to kick students out who were heard chanting the questionable lyrics?
Students generally do not shed their rights to freedom of expression “at the schoolhouse gate,” according to the 1969 U.S. Supreme Court decision Tinker vs. Des Moines Independent Community School District. They have rights, too. These rights include the ability to silently protest the Vietnam war or wear political t-shirts, so long as their speech doesn’t impair some legitimate pedagogical interest (like conducting an orderly class, for example). There are other doctrines which might apply to the words in question. Obscenity relates to sexual conduct and pornography, usually in physical form. Illegal Advocacy relates to advocating violation the law. Offensive words could be regulated if they are likely to be seen as a direct personal insult, but a T-shirt stating “F*** the draft,” was not held to be offensive because it was not directed at anyone in particular. The Captive Audience doctrine seeks to prevent those that cannot help but “hear” the offensive speech. The Captive Audience doctrine looks like it might apply here, but a common foil to that argument is that those who don’t like the message should simply avert their ears. Surely the student section would agree.
Although, really, here we aren’t dealing with students as much as we are dealing with people. People speaking on government property, which invokes the public forum doctrine. The public forum doctrine centers around government-owned property and a citizen’s right to speak on it.
There are three types of government-owned property that have varying degrees of speech regulation:
In his excellent 2009 Kansas Law Review article, Christopher J. Kaufman states that “cheering speech,” which is often directed at teams, players, coaches and other fans, is often loud, obvious, and a big part of college athletics. The offensive chants that are the subject of so much controversy usually erupt from the Student Section. And a lot of times, fans are encouraged to heckle the other team (such as booing the other team as it runs out of the locker room). He also argues that while stadiums are not traditional public fora, they are limited public fora because before, during and after games, fans are essentially encouraged to clap, yell, and chant together in unison. He states that “so long as the government keeps sports stadiums and arenas open for cheering speech, the government may impose restrictions on speech that are content-neutral and narrowly tailored to further significant governmental interests, but it must “leave open ample alternative channels of communication.” (cite: 57 U. Kan. L. Rev. 1235)
He argues that in cases like LSU’s, the school would have to impose a content-neutral ban on all cheering in order to get by constitutional scrutiny. Good luck with that at a school like LSU, or any school that values fans for that matter. It appears that LSU has it right in taking cheers away, because expelling those engaging in the vulgar speech from the game might implicate tricky First Amendment rights that the school doesn’t want to have to navigate.
November 2, 2010 Leave a comment
The LHC in New Orleans sends over a Media Law-related announcement:
On Wednesday, November 3rd, the LHC continues “The New Orleans Media: A Series of Panel Discussions on the Fourth Estate in the City.” The third installment, “The Economics of Newspapers,” features Renette Dejoie Hall (Louisiana Weekly), Peter Kovacs (The Times-Picayune), and Greg LaRose (City Business) in a conversation moderated by writer Jed Horne. Doors open at 6:45 and the panel begins at 7pm.
The LHC is located at 930 Lafayette Street in the New Orleans Central Business District. I know both Kovacs and Horne, and they are both big promoters of a free press, particularly in a city like New Orleans.
October 31, 2010 Leave a comment
The Louisiana Speech Law Blog is now online and ready to Rock ‘n’ Roll. Happy Halloween everyone!
Big Props to friend-of-the-blog Courtney Wilburn at C. Whimsy Designs for our new cool banner logo. Send her your business and you won’t regret it.
Well, this is our first official week of blogging. So we will be on the lookout for free-speech related stories in Louisiana, and don’t forget to send us a tip at laspeechlaw@gmail.com if you see anything worth a post!
A new post is planned for later this week! Enjoy the Nov. 2 elections (we definitely will) and until then, and be sure to vote!
October 24, 2010 8 Comments
The Baton Rouge Advocate reports today that the ACLU of Louisiana is protesting a new policy moving the parish’s trick-or-treating to Monday, Nov. 1 from the traditional Oct. 31 because this year, Oct. 31 falls on a Sunday.

Sunday is traditionally a religious holiday, and rural Livingston Parish has decided that costumed kids and free candy doesn’t fit well with the Sabbath.
However, The Advocate also reports that a lot of residents, including the Parish President, are ignoring the ordinance, and the ACLU of Louisiana seems to be on the side of residents and some local politicians in this letter.
But the ACLU’s legal argument is an interesting one, it is two-fold, according to the letter:
1. Halloween is a Religious Holiday, and its observance should not be abrogated by a Parish Council’s Ordinance
2. The Louisiana and U.S. Constitutions provide a right of free assembly, which prohibits the Livingston Parish Council from telling people they can knock on doors and ask for candy any night of the week, much less Halloween.
What do you think?